ABC Home | Radio | TV | News | Local | Environment | More Subjects… | Shop

Hot topics: australia, sport, rugby-league, nrl, nsw, government-and-politics, community-and-society, wa, united-states, cricket

Former top cop not guilty in perjury case

By Sarah Farnsworth

Posted February 9, 2010 10:38:00
Updated February 9, 2010 12:11:00

The court was told Mr Ashby has been found not guilty on all charges..

The court was told Mr Ashby has been found not guilty on all charges. (ABC TV)

The perjury case against former senior Victorian policeman Noel Ashby has collapsed, with a court finding him not guilty on all charges.

Mr Ashby was facing 11 counts of giving false evidence to a secret Office of Police Integrity (OPI) hearing in 2007.

Last week, Justice Robert Osborn ruled the evidence given by Mr Ashby to the OPI investigation was inadmissible due to a legal technicality.

The investigation was into an alleged chain of leaks that derailed a murder investigation.

Former judge Murray Wilcox QC conducted the hearings as a delegate of the OPI, under oath. But Mr Osborn ruled last week that due to a technicality, that oath was invalid.

In response to the ruling, prosecutor Chris Ryan SC today told the Supreme Court the case against Mr Ashby would be dropped.

Outside the court, Mr Ashby said on legal advice he was unable to make any comment.

Last year, perjury charges against former Police Association secretary Paul Mullett, arising from the same OPI hearing, were also dropped.

Mr Mullett told Fairfax Radio he would seek legal advice about pursuing further action in light of today's court ruling.

"We can talk about the Office of Police Integrity as an entity, but there are a number of individuals that have to be made accountable," he said.

Mr Mullett says this should spell the end of the OPI.

"Today has got to be the final nail in its coffin."

"What was this investigation all about? The big question in that was was it politically motivated?"

The director of the OPI, Michael Strong, admits the outcome is embarrassing but he stands by its record.

"Look obviously there will be some damage to the OPI," he said.

"But I would sincerely hope that what has occurred doesn't negate OPI's excellent record of service to the community, the work the OPI has done in strengthening ethical and professional standards in Victoria Police."

Tags: law-crime-and-justice, courts-and-trials, police, australia, vic, melbourne-3000

ABC News Online Investigative Unit

The ABC News Online Investigative Unit encourages whistleblowers, and others with access to information they believe should be revealed for the public good, to contact us.

  1. Keryn and unindentified girl (face pixelated) on board Scientology ship 'Child slave'

    Former Scientologist breaks silence on "nightmare childhood" after Senate blocks a full inquiry into the organisation.

  2. Contraceptive pill Pill may prevent cancer

    Australian experts are divided over British research which says the pill is good for women.

  3. Thai red shirts set for protest Red tide

    Thousands of Thaksin Shinawatra's supporters protested across Bangkok in a prelude a million-strong march on Sunday.

  4. Luwak poo sits in baskets ready for grading and sorting A matter of taste

    Kevin Rudd has been presented with the most expensive and most fabled coffee in the world.